Car insurance is a policy that protects car owners against financial loss due to accidents or theft. It typically covers damages caused to third-party vehicles, property, or individuals and damage to the insured vehicle. In exchange for paying a premium, car insurance companies assume the financial responsibility of covering the expenses related to car accidents or theft.
The permissibility of car insurance depends on whether the insurance policy aligns with the principles of Islamic finance, which prohibits interest (riba), uncertainty (gharar), and gambling (maysir). Islamic insurance, or takaful, is an alternative to conventional insurance that adheres to Islamic finance principles. This blog aims to provide an informative and engaging resource for Muslims seeking guidance on whether car insurance is halal or haram.
Keynote
- Conventional car Insurance schemes involve two haram elements: gambling (qimaar) and interest (riba).
- Most fiqh councils and fatwas forbid commercial insurance as it exists today, if it is optional and not obligatory.
- If car insurance is compulsory and one has no choice, then it is permissible to take it out, and the sin is on those who forced others to do it.
- Islamic Scholars Shaykh Ibn ‘Uthaymeen and Shaykh Saalih al-Fawzaan argue that car insurance is a form of gambling that consumes people’s wealth unlawfully and leads to carelessness while driving.
- Instead of relying on car insurance, people should trust Allah and be patient and responsible in case of accidents.
Is Car Insurance Haram?
Car insurance is haram due to interest and gambling. Takaful is halal and based on mutual cooperation. It is permissible to get conventional insurance if you are forced to do so. It is important to carefully review and choose insurance policies that align with Islamic values.
Why is Car Insurance Haram?
Car insurance has become a common practice in many countries around the world. However, for Muslims, there is a growing concern regarding the permissibility of car insurance in Islamic Finance. Here are the top 3 reasons why car insurance is considered haram:
1. Gharar (Uncertainty)
Gharar is an Islamic term to describe a transaction involving an uncertain outcome. Car insurance is based on the principle of uncertainty, which means that the policyholder is uncertain about the future occurrence of an accident, and the insurer is uncertain about the amount of compensation they will have to pay in the event of a claim. This uncertainty makes the transaction invalid in Islamic Finance.
“And do not consume one another’s wealth unjustly or send it [in bribery] to the rulers in order that [they might aid] you [to] consume a portion of the wealth of the people in sin, while you know [it is unlawful].” (Surah Al-Baqarah, 2:188)
“O you who have believed, indeed, intoxicants, gambling, [sacrificing on] stone alters [to other than Allah], and divining arrows are but defilement from the work of Satan, so avoid it that you may be successful.” (Surah Al-Maidah, 5:90)
Narrated by Abu Hurairah: “The Messenger of Allah (ﷺ) forbade transactions determined by throwing stones, and transactions which involved some uncertainty (Gharar).” (Authentic Grade: Hasan)
Narrated by Abu Hurairah: “The Messenger of Allah (ﷺ) forbade a transaction in which Gharar is present, and a transaction in which two parties engage in a game of chance (Maisir).” (Authentic Grade: Sahih)
2. Riba (Interest)
Riba is the Arabic term used to describe any transaction involving an increase in capital without exchanging an equivalent amount of goods or services. Car insurance involves the payment of premiums, which are essentially payments for a service that has not yet been provided. This can be considered as riba, which is strictly prohibited in Islam.
“Allah destroys interest and gives increase for charities. And Allah does not like every sinning disbeliever.” (Surah Al-Baqarah, 276)
“And [for] their taking of usury while they had been forbidden from it, and their consuming of the people’s wealth unjustly. And we have prepared for the disbelievers among them a painful punishment.” (Surah An-Nisa, Verse 161)
Narrated by Jabir ibn Abdullah: “The Prophet (peace be upon him) cursed the one who consumes riba, the one who gives it, the one who records it, and the two witnesses to the transaction, and said, ‘They are all alike [in sin].'” (Authentic Grade: Sahih)
3. Maysir (Gambling)
Maysir is an Islamic term to describe any transaction involving gambling or speculation. Car insurance can be seen as a form of gambling, as the policyholder is essentially betting on the likelihood of an accident occurring, and the insurer is betting on the likelihood of the policyholder making a claim. This form of speculation is considered haram in Islam.
Surah Al-Maida, Verse 90: “O you who have believed, indeed, intoxicants, gambling, [sacrificing on] stone alters [to other than Allah], and divining arrows are but defilement from the work of Satan, so avoid it that you may be successful.”
Types of Car Insurance Coverage
| Type Name | How it Works |
|---|---|
| Third-party liability insurance | Covers damages caused by the insured vehicle to third-party vehicles, property, or individuals. It does not cover damages to the insured vehicle. |
| Comprehensive insurance | Covers damages caused by the insured vehicle to third-party vehicles, property, or individuals and damages to the insured vehicle caused by accidents, theft, or natural disasters. |
| Collision insurance | Covers damages to the insured vehicle caused by collisions with other vehicles or objects. |
| Personal injury protection (PIP) | Covers medical expenses and lost wages for the insured and their passengers in the event of an accident. |
| Uninsured motorist insurance | Covers damages caused by uninsured or underinsured drivers. |
What Is the Difference Between Halal and Haram Car Insurance?
Here are the top 5 differences between conventional insurance and Islamic insurance (takaful):
| Difference | Conventional Insurance | Islamic Insurance (Takaful) |
|---|---|---|
| Ownership | The policyholder transfers the risk to the insurance company | The policyholder participates in a mutual fund, where risks are shared among the policyholders |
| Investment | The insurance company invests the premiums in interest-based instruments | The takaful fund is invested in Shariah-compliant investments |
| Profit | The insurance company keeps the profits from investing the premiums | The profits from the takaful fund are distributed among the policyholders based on a pre-agreed ratio |
| Transparency | The terms and conditions of the policy may be complex and difficult to understand | The takaful contract is transparent and clearly outlines the rights and obligations of the parties involved. |
| Social Responsibility | The insurance company may not have a social responsibility mandate | The takaful fund may include a charitable component, where a portion of the profits is donated to a charitable cause |
What To Do When I Have No Alternative?
Muslims who cannot afford or find takaful insurance can consider the following options:
- Seek help from family, friends, or the community in case of an accident or theft.
- To avoid riba in car insurance, Muslims should opt for takaful insurance, which operates on a mutual fund basis. Risks are shared among the policyholders, and profits are distributed in a pre-agreed ratio.
- The solution to the issue of gharar in car insurance is also opt for takaful insurance. Takaful insurance operates on the principles of transparency, mutual cooperation, and shared responsibility, which align with Islamic finance principles.
- Choose third-party insurance, which only covers damages caused to third-party property or individuals and not to the insured vehicle. This type of insurance is generally less expensive than comprehensive coverage.
- Negotiate the terms of the conventional insurance contract to minimize the involvement of riba, gharar, or maysir (If no alternative is found). For example, the policyholder can ask for a fixed premium instead of a premium based on the insured vehicle’s value or negotiate a lower deductible. It is essential to read the policy’s terms and conditions carefully and consult an Islamic finance expert to ensure that the insurance policy complies with Islamic finance principles.
Note: It is crucial for Muslims to fulfill their legal obligations, including the legal requirement to have car insurance in many countries. However, if a Muslim is unintentionally involved in haram activities related to car insurance, they should seek forgiveness from Allah and make efforts to rectify the situation as soon as possible.
Read More: Is disability insurance halal?
Is Paying Car Insurance Monthly Haram or Halal?
Paying car insurance monthly may or may not be considered haram (prohibited) in Islam, depending on the type of car insurance policy and the way in which the monthly payments are structured. Generally, if the monthly payments include any form of interest or riba, it would be considered haram. However, if the payments are structured in a way that does not involve any interest or riba, then it would be permissible or halal.
For example, in a takaful car insurance policy, the participants pool their funds to create a common pool of funds that is used to pay for any claims. The participants pay a fixed contribution to the pool based on their individual risk profile and the estimated cost of claims. The contribution is not considered as interest or riba, as it is used to fund the mutual pool of funds and not to generate any profit for the insurance company. In this case, paying car insurance monthly would be halal if the contribution is fixed and not based on any interest.
On the other hand, in a conventional car insurance policy, the monthly payments may include interest or finance charges, which are added to the policy’s total cost. In this case, paying car insurance monthly would be haram, as it would involve paying interest or riba.
Is Car Insurance Mandatory in the UK?
Yes, car insurance is mandatory in the UK. According to the Road Traffic Act 1930, driving a motor vehicle on a public road in the UK is illegal without valid insurance. This applies to all drivers, including those who only drive occasionally or for short periods.
The minimum level of car insurance required by law in the UK is third-party insurance, which covers the cost of damage or injury to other people and their property, but does not cover the cost of damage to your own vehicle. There are also higher levels of cover available, such as third-party, fire and theft insurance and comprehensive insurance.
According to the Association of British Insurers (ABI), the average cost of car insurance in the UK was £465 in the fourth quarter of 2020. This decreased 3% compared to the previous year, partly due to the Covid-19 pandemic and reduced driving activity. However, the cost of car insurance can vary widely depending on factors such as age, driving history, location, and type of vehicle.
In a statement on their website, the UK government states, “It is a legal requirement to have at least third party car insurance cover to drive on UK roads.” Failure to have valid car insurance can result in various penalties, including fines, penalty points on your driving license, and even disqualification from driving.
Is Car Insurance Mandatory in the USA in Every State?
Car insurance is mandatory in the USA in every state except New Hampshire. However, even in this states, drivers are required to have some form of financial responsibility in the event of an accident.
In the other 49 states, drivers must have a minimum level of car insurance coverage, which typically includes liability insurance to cover the cost of damage or injury to other people and their property. The specific requirements for car insurance can vary by state, with some requiring higher coverage levels than others.
According to a 2021 report by the Insurance Information Institute (III), the average cost of car insurance in the USA was $1,134 per year in 2018. However, the cost of car insurance can vary widely depending on factors such as age, driving history, location, and type of vehicle.
The consequences for driving without car insurance can also vary by state. In some states, drivers who are caught without insurance can face fines, license suspension, and even impoundment of their vehicle. In other states, drivers involved in accidents without insurance may be personally liable for damages or injuries, which can result in significant financial hardship.
Is Working for Insurance Companies Haram?
Is selling life insurance haram? In Islam, selling or buying anything that is haram (prohibited) is not allowed. Therefore, if a car insurance policy contains elements that are haram, such as riba (interest), gharar (uncertainty), or maysir (gambling), then selling or buying that insurance policy would also be haram.
However, there are car insurance policies available that are designed to be Shariah-compliant and do not contain any haram elements. These policies are structured in a way that aligns with Islamic principles, such as mutual cooperation, shared responsibility, and solidarity. Examples of such policies include takaful car insurance and cooperative insurance.
If you are working in the car insurance industry and wish to avoid selling haram car insurance policies, you should seek out and promote Shariah-compliant alternatives, such as takaful car insurance. By doing so, you can ensure that you are acting in accordance with Islamic principles and helping to meet the needs of Muslim customers who wish to protect their vehicles while adhering to their faith.
Final Thoughts
Car insurance can be haram if it contains elements that are not permissible in Islam, such as riba (interest), gharar (uncertainty), and maysir (gambling). However, car insurance options are designed to align with Islamic principles, such as takaful car insurance and cooperative insurance. These options operate on mutual cooperation, shared responsibility, and solidarity and do not contain haram elements.
As Muslims, it is important to align all aspects of our lives with Islamic principles, including car insurance. Therefore, we should carefully review the terms and conditions of any car insurance policy before making any payments and seek the advice of Islamic scholars or experts in Islamic finance to ensure that the policy is Shariah-compliant.
Furthermore, it is important to note that car insurance is mandatory in many countries, including the UK and the USA. Therefore, as Muslims, we should seek out and promote Shariah-compliant alternatives to conventional car insurance and ensure that we act in accordance with Islamic principles while still adhering to legal requirements.
Halal Car Insurance (FAQs)
How can I ensure that my car insurance is not haram according to Islamic principles?
To ensure that your car insurance is not haram according to Islamic principles, you should opt for an insurance policy that is Shariah-compliant and adheres to the principles of Takaful. Takaful is a cooperative system of mutual assistance based on the principles of shared responsibility, solidarity, and brotherhood, and it is considered the halal alternative to conventional insurance.
How do I find halal car insurance in the UK?
You can find halal car insurance in the UK by searching for Takaful-based insurance policies that comply with Shariah principles.
How can I explain to non-Muslims why some Muslims avoid car insurance?
You can explain to non-Muslims that some Muslims avoid conventional car insurance because it involves riba and gharar, considered major sins in Islam. However, Islam encourages Muslims to take precautions and protect themselves and their possessions, which includes owning car insurance. Therefore, many Muslims opt for Takaful-based insurance policies that comply with Shariah principles.
What are the main arguments for why car insurance is haram in Islam?
The main arguments for why car insurance is haram in Islam are that it involves riba (usury) and gharar (uncertainty), considered major sins in Islam. Riba refers to the interest or premium charged by conventional insurance companies, which is prohibited in Islam, while gharar refers to the uncertainty and ambiguity involved in conventional insurance contracts. Therefore, many Islamic scholars consider conventional car insurance haram.